Mine won’t stay closed. My stomach is probably pushing it down, and the magnets aren’t aligned when that happens. They could have made it work for fat people, put bigger magnets on part of it.

A fanny pack might have been a better idea, I can put everything in there, probably cheaper as well.

The old holster with the loose belt thing has no issues staying closed.

Oh and the new smaller one, makes my phone warm as well. That’s not good for the life span of my phone. Does the other one make my phone warm? I don’t recall.

It stays shut when sitting, or if I have a jacket on. When walking around without a jacket, it pops open. I’m too lazy to send it back, and too cheap to order a bigger one.

I’ll lookup fanny packs instead. That’s what old men wear. Nice, that one has a water bottle holder. That’s way more handy.

I don’t use my pockets for my phone, it might fall out. My keys have fallen out.

Not to mention, it’s a pain in the ass to get on my belt. I can’t exactly see what I’m doing, that doesn’t matter for the old bigger one.

Most of the fanny packs on Amazon are probably junk, just like their phone holsters.